The "UnBeataBears" Stun Newburgh in Rivalry Thriller to Remain Undefeated

Photo Credit: Mike Heit

Rain poured down on Faller Field as Middletown faced its biggest test of the season.

Trailing Newburgh 22-19 with less than two minutes remaining, the Middie Bears' undefeated season hung in the balance.

The pounding of the bleachers and erupting chants created a raucous environment, as Middletown needed one final touchdown to keep its perfect record intact.

The pressure intensified. Hearts pounded. Palms grew sweaty as both communities held their breath for what came next. However, Newburgh made one mistake: leaving enough time on the clock for Jojo Royal, giving him one last chance to deliver.

They wouldn't be disappointed.

PRESENTED BY

Exclusive Presenting Partner of DJ’s Sports Show’s 2026 Middletown Football Coverage

START YOUR JOURNEY TODAY →

A Stormy Start to a Highly Anticipated Rivalry

As I drove down the highway toward Middletown, a looming rainstorm stretched across the sky. It was a fitting backdrop for one of Section 9's most anticipated matchups: the undefeated Middie Bears against the Newburgh Goldbacks.

Fans packed Faller Field, eager to watch Section 9's finest programs collide in a rivalry that has produced memorable moments throughout its history. However, thunder delayed the start as spectators waited anxiously to take their seats in the bleachers.

Once the game finally began, the Middie Bears wasted little time making their presence felt.

A block-in-the-back penalty against Newburgh pushed Middletown back toward its own 15-yard line on the opening possession.

After a first-down by Andy Aristhene and several short plays, Royal connected with Ryheem Tinsley Jr., who bolted 68 yards downfield for the touchdown. Mario DeGiorgio converted the extra point, giving Middletown an early 7-0 lead, igniting the home crowd.

Tinsley celebrating with his teammate Justin Stewart (1) after striking into the end zone.

Photo Credit: Mike Heit

However, Newburgh struck back.

Responding with its powerful rushing attack. Running back Zaire Jacklyn broke through multiple tackles as the Goldbacks advanced toward midfield, while Justin Lassic helped push the offense deep into Middletown territory.

Nyeir Johnson finished the drive with a four-yard rushing touchdown, tying the game at 7-7 with 5:05 remaining in the first quarter.

Middletown immediately threatened to regain the lead. Royal rapidly moved the offense downfield, while penalties against Newburgh helped the Middie Bears advance inside the 10-yard line.

However, Newburgh's defense stiffened near the goal line, forcing a turnover on downs. The Goldbacks took over at their own five-yard line as the opening quarter ended tied 7-7.

Friday Night Films

Newburgh Takes Control as Middletown Stays Close

Newburgh opened the second quarter with a 39-yard rushing gain, continuing to challenge Middletown's defense on the ground.

A holding penalty briefly disrupted the Goldbacks' momentum on a 2nd-and-18 near midfield. However, Newburgh overcame the setback, moving inside Middletown's 30-yard line before an unnecessary roughness penalty against the Middie Bears pushed the visitors farther downfield.

Johnson eventually powered into the end zone for his second rushing touchdown, giving Newburgh its first lead at 14-7.

Just as the Goldbacks were making a run, Middletown appeared to unravel. Penalties and unforced mistakes pushed the Middie Bears dangerously close to their own goal line, leaving the offense searching for another explosive play.

Royal and Tinsley delivered.

For the second time in the half, Royal connected with his dynamic playmaker, who broke free for a spectacular 91-yard touchdown reception. However, a missed extra point prevented Middletown from tying the game, leaving Newburgh ahead 14-13.

Ryheem Tinsley Jr. rushing into the end zone.

Photo Credit: Mike Heit

The Goldbacks nearly answered with a touchdown. Barnwell found Jeron Underwood downfield, but a holding and an ineligible-receiver penalty negated the play, pushing Newburgh back to its own 28-yard line.

Newburgh fought for yardage as Denvyr Herring made a remarkable one-handed catch with his left hand, leaving the crowd in awe and giving the Goldbacks another first down.

Despite the spectacular reception, Middletown's defense prevented Newburgh from extending its lead. The Goldbacks punted with 40 seconds remaining, as the Middie Bears failed to score before halftime.

After a first half filled with explosive plays, costly penalties, and momentum swings, Newburgh entered the break holding a narrow 14-13 lead.

Middletown Reclaims the Lead Behind Royal and Tinsley

The third quarter began with another penalty against Newburgh, as an unsportsmanlike conduct call backed the Goldbacks up to their own 40-yard line. Middletown's defense forced a punt, allowing Royal and the offense to reclaim the lead.

Once again, the connection between Royal and Tinsley proved crucial.

Tinsley hauled in another significant gain, helping Middletown advance inside Newburgh's 15-yard line. A false-start penalty briefly pushed the Middie Bears backward, but Royal found Tinsley again, moving the offense inside the five.

Royal finished the drive himself, powering into the end zone for a two-yard rushing touchdown.

Middletown failed to convert the two-point attempt but reclaimed the lead at 19-14 with 3:31 remaining in the third quarter. While the Middie Bears offense was clicking, so did their defense. Middletown's defense built momentum, forcing another Newburgh punt. This allowing Middletown to extend its advantage entering the final quarter.

But the Goldbacks weren't finished.

Newburgh Rallies as the Rivalry Reaches Its Breaking Point

Rain poured over Faller Field again in the fourth, as Middletown looked to protect its five-point lead.

A holding penalty pushed the Middie Bears back to Newburgh's 34-yard line. Another unsportsmanlike conduct penalty against the Goldbacks led to an ejection and helped Middletown advance to the eight-yard line.

A barrage of "Boos" erupted from the Newburgh crowd as emotions intensified.

Middletown was poised to extend its lead, but penalties and a crucial dropped third-down pass stalled the drive. The Middie Bears eventually turned the ball over on downs, giving Newburgh possession with 8:09 remaining.

The Goldbacks had another opportunity to take control.

Barnwell nearly connected with Underwood for a potential go-ahead touchdown, but the pass fell incomplete. Newburgh prepared to punt on fourth down before a costly roughing-the-kicker penalty against Middletown gave the Goldbacks new life.

The penalty extended Newburgh's possession as the offense positioned near midfield. Barnwell then broke loose for a 20-yard gain, moving the Goldbacks to Middletown's 28-yard line as their offense began finding its rhythm.

Herring eventually rushed into the end zone for the go-ahead touchdown, and Barnwell converted the two-point attempt to give Newburgh a 22-19 lead with just 1:43 remaining.

The visiting crowd erupted in chanting "Newburgh!" as the Goldbacks stood on the verge of handing Middletown its first loss of the season.

For the Middie Bears, everything came down to one final drive.

Royal Delivers a Comeback for the Ages

With two timeouts and less than two minutes remaining, Middletown needed a touchdown to reclaim the lead.

The pressure was unmistakable. Fans stomped their feet against the bleachers as chants echoed throughout Faller Field, creating a tense atmosphere for the final moments of a fiercely contested rivalry.

The pressure didn't shake Middletown. Royal and the Middie Bears went to work.

The Middletown quarterback connected with Zayden Phillpotts for crucial first downs before finding Aristhene to move the Middie Bears to Newburgh's 22-yard line. A sack threatened to derail the comeback, forcing Middletown to call a timeout.

Coming out of the stoppage, Royal found Tinsley, who stepped out of bounds near Newburgh's 10-yard line as the inevitable comeback loomed. An encroachment penalty against Newburgh moved the Middie Bears closer to the goal line.

It was now or never, and Royal took matters into his own hands.

Royal rumbled from five yards out into the end zone for the go-ahead rushing touchdown, sending the Middletown crowd into a frenzy as the Middie Bears reclaimed the lead at 25-22. Mario DeGiorgio converted the extra point, giving the Middie Bears a 26-22 lead with approximately 30 seconds remaining.

Newburgh still had one final opportunity to answer, but Middletown's defense delivered the decisive blow. Barnwell dropped back to pass; however, Andrew Smith intercepted it for a pick-six.

The pick-six sent Faller Field into celebration as Middletown extended its lead to 33-22 after the extra point, putting the finishing touches on a remarkable rivalry.

The "UnBeataBears" Make History

Middletown's 33-22 victory wasn't simply another addition to its undefeated record.

The Middie Bears overcame a weather delay, costly penalties, and a late Newburgh touchdown that threatened to end their perfect season. Phillpotts and Aristhene made timely catches. But it was Royal and Tinsley who led the charge for the Middie Bears all night.

Tinsley delivered a remarkable performance, finishing with 256 receiving yards and two receiving touchdowns on seven receptions. His explosive 68-yard and 91-yard scoring receptions helped Middletown in the first half.

Royal on the other hand completed on 13-of-17 pass attempts for 326 yards and two touchdowns along with two rushing touchdowns.

The win carried historical significance. After defeating Newburgh 21-16 on the road last season, Middletown has now secured back-to-back victories over its Section 9 rival. The Middie Bears also defeated the Goldbacks at Faller Field for the first time since 1995, ending a 31-year drought.

The "UnBeataBears" are now 7-0, having found yet another way to win when adversity struck.

Next Friday, Middletown will face the Monroe-Woodbury Crusaders at 6 p.m. ET as the Middie Bears look to extend their undefeated season.

But this night belonged to Middletown.

Under the stormy skies of Faller Field, the Middie Bears didn't just protect their perfect record. They delivered a comeback that will be remembered in this rivalry in the years to come.

Listen to the Middletown Minute:

Go beyond the article and hear DJ Hamilton talk with Middletown players all season long.

Stay Connected With DJ's Sports Show

Subscribe to DJ's Sports Digest for the latest stories, interviews, and Middletown football coverage coming soon.