Middletown Football Defeats Monroe Woodbury in Epic Senior Night Performance

Brett B Photos

For Middletown's seniors, Friday night at Faller Field was about more than football.

Parents gathered to celebrate their children, cherishing the bittersweet milestone of Senior Night as the Middie Bears prepared for their final home game of the regular season.

It was an evening filled with pride, reflection, and celebration. However, once the festivities concluded, Middletown turned its attention to longtime rival Monroe Woodbury, looking to finish its regular season home schedule undefeated against the Crusaders.

The Middie Bears made sure their seniors would have another reason to remember the night

And the Middie Bears were only getting started.

PRESENTED BY

Exclusive Presenting Partner of DJ’s Sports Show’s 2026 Middletown Football Coverage

START YOUR JOURNEY TODAY →

Middletown Sets the Tone With First Quarter Onslaught

Monroe opened the game with a quick three-and-out, giving Middletown's explosive offense an early opportunity to establish control. A holding penalty initially pushed the Middie Bears backward, but Andy Aristhene recovered the lost yardage for a first down.

Middletown never looked back. Continuing his remarkable season, Ryheem Tinsley Jr. slithered through the Crusaders' defense, spinning away from multiple Crusader defenders on a 26-yard touchdown run that ignited the crowd.

The missed extra point left Middletown ahead 6-0, but the Middie Bears were only getting started.

Middletown's defense quickly forced a turnover on downs, setting up at the Crusaders' 35-yard line. Aristhene appeared to break loose for a 30-yard touchdown, but a block in the back penalty negated the score. However, it still led to a Middie Bear first down.

The offense continued toward the end zone, as Tinsley eventually finished the drive with his second rushing touchdown, extending the lead to 12-0. Meanwhile, Monroe's problems were only beginning.

On the ensuing kickoff, the Crusaders fumbled the return, and Jeremiah Sander recovered the football at Monroe's 27-yard line.

An illegal formation penalty briefly pushed Middletown backward, but quarterback Jojo Royal responded by connecting with Zayden Phillpotts for a 32-yard touchdown.

Middletown failed to convert the two-point attempt, leaving the score at 18-0. However, the Middie Bears continued capitalizing on Monroe-Woodbury's mistakes as another fumble gave them possession at the Crusaders' 23-yard line.

Despite another penalty, Tinsley erased 15 yards with a rushing gain that brought Middletown closer to the goal line. Aristhene eventually powered into the end zone from seven yards out, capping a stunning opening quarter as the Middie Bears built a commanding 24-0 lead.

Middletown's Offensive Explosion Continues

The second quarter brought little relief for Monroe-Woodbury as the Crusaders nearly threw an interception before another penalty complicated their possession. Middletown then blocked the ensuing punt, setting up its offense inside the five-yard line.

Royal capitalized immediately, finding Justin Stewart for his second touchdown pass of the game.

The successful extra point extended Middletown's lead to 31-0 with 10:47 remaining in the first half as the Middie Bears continued overwhelming the Crusaders on both sides of the ball.

Tinsley added his third rushing touchdown of the evening, scoring from 16 yards out to stretch the lead to 37-0 with 6:30 remaining before halftime. Middletown's offensive explosiveness showed no signs of slowing down as Royal continued attacking the Crusaders' secondary.

On another possession, Royal delivered downfield to Aristhene and Tinsley, as both players appeared to catch the ball inside the Crusaders' 10-yard line. The Middie Bears continued advancing before Kervens Paraisy powered through defenders for another touchdown.

By halftime, Middletown led 44-0 over Monroe. What began as a celebration of Middletown's seniors had quickly become one of the team's most dominant offensive performances of the season.

Middletown Finishes Strong

With a commanding lead, Middletown turned to its reserves to give other players a chance to contribute. Meanwhile, the Crusaders finally found some success offensively after struggling throughout the opening two quarters.

Monroe moved into Middletown territory as penalties against the Middie Bears helped sustain their drive. Shae Mitchel eventually scored on a two-yard rushing touchdown, finally putting the Crusaders on the scoreboard as Middletown held a commanding 44-6 lead through three quarters.

Monroe added another rushing touchdown from Mitchel with nine seconds left in the fourth quarter, but the outcome had long been decided.

Middletown's special teams also contributed to the dominant performance, highlighted by a blocked kick and a kickoff return touchdown by Stewart to end the game in exhilarating fashion.

When the final whistle sounded, the Middie Bears sealed a 50-12 rout, completing an undefeated home regular season and continuing their remarkable run.

A Historic Senior Night for the UnBeataBears

Middletown's victory carried significance beyond its undefeated record, marking the program's first home win over Monroe since 2001 while snapping a five-game losing streak against the Crusaders.

The Middie Bears also tied their program record for points scored against Monroe-Woodbury. Meanwhile, the Crusaders surrendered 50 points for the first time since 2002, adding another historical milestone to an unforgettable evening at Faller Field.

For Middletown, the performance reflected the qualities that have defined its undefeated season. Tinsley scored three rushing touchdowns, Royal distributed the football to his playmakers, and the defense and special teams repeatedly created opportunities.

However, perhaps the most meaningful part of the evening belonged to the seniors who helped build the program into what it has become.

On a night when families gathered to celebrate their journeys, the Middie Bears gave their graduating players a final regular season home memory worth cherishing.

The "UnBeataBears" are now 8-0 and will travel to Kingston next Friday at 6 p.m. ET, looking to finish the regular season undefeated before postseason play begins.

Listen to the Middletown Minute:

Go beyond the article and hear DJ Hamilton talk with Middletown players all season long.

Stay Connected With DJ's Sports Show

Subscribe to DJ's Sports Digest for the latest stories, interviews, and Middletown football coverage coming soon.